Opinion: To tackle the housing crisis, Carney's federal plan must embrace private sector solutions
Eight years after the BC NDP-led provincial government committed to building 114,000 affordable homes over 10 years, BC Housing figures show that the various provincial funding programs directly resulted in only 3,178 completions during the 2023/24 fiscal year, and just 20,422 over the past five years.
At this pace, it will take 28 years to deliver the promised 114,000 homes.
The results are so far off the stated goal that the provincial government has resorted to padding their news releases with housing they had no part in building.
When someone is forced to leave B.C. to find work in Alberta and rents out their home in Kelowna, that is celebrated as a successful increase in rental housing under the BC NDP’s creative accounting.
Further, as usual when politicians take up a cause, the rationale for some of their projects is questionable.
For example, the provincial government is planning a new affordable housing project on the prime site of the former ICBC headquarters office beside Lonsdale Quay in North Vancouver, two city blocks on the waterfront, with sweeping views over Burrard Inlet. Construction will be complex and expensive; the building is perched above the North Shore’s primary bus loop, and crosses over a road and railway tunnel. Perfect location for affordable, government-funded housing, right?
As part of its BC Builds program, the Province recently announced that it had selected a partner to construct 110 affordable rental units at Sun Peaks Mountain Resort.
The homeless population in the City of Vancouver alone (2,400) is larger than the entire population of Sun Peaks (1,400), and yet the Province is focused on building expensive waterfront projects, and employee housing at private mountain resorts.
The provincial Rental Protection Fund provides another example of what happens when politics and the love of a good press conference trump results-based decision-making.
The fund has “protected” 125 homes in Port Hardy, a population of 3,900 residents, where one-bedroom suites rent for $900 per month and redevelopment pressure is non-existent. Another 153 units have been “protected” in nearby Campbell River. In Vancouver, home to the highest rents in the country, the fund has supported only 57 units so far.
Is the goal to deliver affordable housing where it will have the greatest impact, or to fly
politicians to BC NDP ridings where they can tout their good work in front of a flashy podium?
We need efficient solutions to deliver significantly more homes in a cost-effective way. Whatever the plan, the government will need to include the private sector to achieve any kind of scale.
One idea getting no noticeable attention would be to subsidize the mandated inclusionary zoning units that have become ubiquitous across Metro Vancouver. In the City of Vancouver’s Broadway Plan area alone, there are 3,500 proposed below-market affordable rental units in 110 projects currently in the pipeline that are at risk of never seeing the light of day.
At a conservative estimate of current construction rates, these units will cost about double their value on completion, resulting in a $250,000 to $300,000 loss to the developer, per unit. Because market rents have softened, developers can’t recover this shortfall from other tenants, so most of these 110 projects will sit on the shelf, unable to get financing.
Waiting for rents to increase to fund these projects is a bad option.
If cities continue to insist on weighing down projects with unprofitable units, developers are going to need some help, or nothing will get built. Here, then, is an opportunity for government to deliver a significant amount of below-market housing in partnership with the private sector.
As the federal government tackles the housing file, let’s hope they focus on creating results,
rather than just selling the sizzle.
- You might also like:
- B.C.'s Rental Protection Fund reaches milestone of 1,500 rental home acquisitions
- ICBC's existing Lonsdale headquarters office building to be redeveloped for new affordable housing development
- Former Vancouver mayor Gregor Robertson will handle housing for all of Canada under Carney
- Carney capping immigration further to ease lack of housing in Canada
- This is how Canada's new GST cuts on home sales up to $1.5 million for first-time buyers will work